Q1: Do I agree with the authors prospective on what should be taught in the high school classroom?
A1: NO. How can you say that teaching universal rules and principles does not prepare students for the real world? I know that there are plenty of teachers out there that really do not care whether or not their students learn anything. However, when become a history teacher, along with the regular curriculum I plan on teaching universal rules and principles, which to me means teaching what it means to be a responsible, knowledgeable citizen with good morals and a positive outlook on life and society.
Q2: Is the high school level too early to begin teaching knowledge and skills for success in real world situations?
A2: NO. I agree that these skills should be taught whenever possible. However, to disregard regular academic skill sets in the classroom is just not a good idea. High school students are going through one of the most unique phases of life, and to disregard the teaching of principles and rules of life is crazy.